Is Melissa & Doug compatible with BRIO? Yes: the same eight-curve circle
Yes. Melissa & Doug wooden railway is the same family as BRIO: a peg at one end and a socket at the other, a 45 degree curve with eight to a circle, and a straight of 8.5 inches, which is 215.9 mm against BRIO’s 216. Melissa & Doug sells its sets as compatible with other wooden railway systems, and nothing that has been measured contradicts it. As with every brand but IKEA, the one figure missing is the radius of the curve.
Links to Amazon are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate this site earns from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. Nothing about you is sent to Amazon by this site; the link simply carries a shop code.
What is published
| Measurement | Melissa & Doug | BRIO |
|---|---|---|
| Straight | 8.5 inches, 215.9 mm, in the name of the pack | 216 mm, the long straight D |
| Curve angle | 45 degrees: eight curves form a complete circle | 45 degrees, eight to a circle |
| Circle of eight curves | described as an 18 inch circle, 457 mm, with no edge named | 444 mm across the outside |
| Curve radius | not published anywhere | 182 mm inside, 202 mm centreline, 222 mm outside |
| Faces | grooved on both, so a curve turns either way | grooved on both |
The 18 inch circle
The only size anyone gives for the Melissa & Doug curve is that eight of them form an 18 inch circle. That is 457 mm, against 444 mm across the outside of a BRIO circle: 13 mm apart. It is a round number in inches with no edge named, which reads as a description rather than a measurement, and working a radius out of it would be a guess. What it does say is that the two curves are close, and that is as much as is known.
Do Melissa & Doug trains run on BRIO track?
Yes. The grooves in wooden track are much the same from make to make, 3 mm deep, 5 mm wide and 20 mm apart, and the one source that measured across brands found them close enough on BRIO, Bigjigs, Thomas and other makes for the trains to run without trouble. A Melissa & Doug train runs on BRIO track, and a BRIO engine on Melissa & Doug.
Mixing the two in a layout
- Mix the straights freely. 215.9 mm and 216 mm are the same piece.
- Build each turn from one brand’s curves. Both turn 45 degrees, so the angle always comes out; it is the unknown radius that can leave a mixed loop a few millimetres apart.
- Check the last joint. Within about 3 mm it goes together, which is the play a BRIO joint is built with. How that play works.
- Count Melissa & Doug pieces as BRIO in the planner.
The big Melissa & Doug set
Melissa & Doug sells its track mostly as one large set rather than in packs of four: 130 pieces, about 100 of them track and supports, with instructions for four layouts. The split by piece is not published, so tip it out and tick the pieces off by hand. Buy on Amazon
The other brands
- Bigjigs Rail — straights measured and matching, curve unpublished.
- IKEA LILLABO — the only third-party curve with a measured radius.
- Hape — sold as compatible, measured by nobody.
- Thomas Wooden Railway — one range fits, one genuinely does not.
- Every brand side by side.